Irresistible Buttermilk Pie: A Holiday Delight

The holiday season brings with it a myriad of cherished traditions, and for many, the joy of festive gatherings is intertwined with the aroma of delightful treats wafting from the kitchen. One such treasured recipe that captures the essence of celebration is the Buttermilk Pie. A creation that beckons secrecy, with one enthusiast confessing to making it in the dead of the night and resorting to covert measures to preserve this delectable dessert from eager family members. Join us on a culinary journey as we unravel the magic behind this irresistible Buttermilk Pie and explore the ingredients, preparation, and the undeniable allure that keeps enthusiasts coming back for more.


  1. 1 3/4 C. sugar
  2. 1 stick unsalted butter (1/2 C.), room temp.
  3. 3 large eggs
  4. 1/4 tsp. vanilla extract
  5. Pinch of salt
  6. 3 T. all-purpose flour
  7. 1 C. buttermilk
  8. 1 9″ pie shell, unbaked


Creating this enchanting Buttermilk Pie is a delightful process that begins with the careful selection and harmonious blending of ingredients. Follow these simple steps to bring the magic to life:

  1. Creaming the Sugar and Butter: Start by combining 1 3/4 cups of sugar and 1/2 cup of unsalted butter (at room temperature) in a mixing bowl. Cream the ingredients together until a smooth and well-blended consistency is achieved.
  2. Incorporating Eggs and Flavorful Additions: Add three large eggs to the sugar-butter mixture one at a time, ensuring each egg is thoroughly incorporated before adding the next. Once the mixture achieves a smooth texture, introduce 1/4 teaspoon of vanilla extract, a pinch of salt, and 3 tablespoons of all-purpose flour. Continue beating the ingredients to create a luscious base for the Buttermilk Pie.
  3. Infusing Buttermilk Brilliance: The star of this recipe, 1 cup of buttermilk, is then added to the batter. Carefully blend until all ingredients are well combined, creating a velvety filling that promises to elevate the pie’s flavor profile.
  4. Prepping the Pie Shell: Place a 9-inch pie shell (unbaked) on a baking sheet lined with foil. This not only ensures easy cleanup but also catches any potential overflow during baking.
  5. Filling the Pie Shell: Pour the buttermilk mixture into the pie shell, filling it just to the top. Any remaining mixture can be poured into an ungreased custard cup, ensuring that no ounce of this delectable concoction goes to waste.
  6. Baking to Perfection: Preheat the oven to 300 degrees and bake the Buttermilk Pie for 1 hour and 10 minutes. The low and slow cooking process allows the flavors to meld and intensify, creating a pie with a perfect balance of sweetness and richness.
  7. Cooling and Storing: Once removed from the oven, let the pie set until it’s almost cooled before serving. This patience is rewarded with a slice that holds its shape and texture. For prolonged enjoyment, store the Buttermilk Pie covered in the refrigerator.


In conclusion, the Buttermilk Pie stands as a testament to the power of simple yet harmonious ingredients, expertly combined to create a dessert that transcends ordinary expectations. The confession of making it in the dead of the night, followed by the need for stealthy tactics to keep it from the clutches of eager family members, speaks volumes about its irresistible allure.

As the aroma of this Buttermilk Pie fills the kitchen during the holiday season, it not only satisfies the palate but also weaves itself into the fabric of cherished memories. The recipe’s straightforward preparation, coupled with the unparalleled satisfaction it brings, ensures that it will remain a staple in festive kitchens for years to come. So, embrace the magic, savor each bite, and let the Buttermilk Pie become a centerpiece of your holiday traditions, beckoning you back for more with each passing celebration.

Leave a Comment